The state in a capitalist society: protests and state reactions in Vietnam and Indonesia/
WISCHERMANN Jörg
The state in a capitalist society: protests and state reactions in Vietnam and Indonesia/ Jörg Wischermann, Thi Viet Phuong Dang & George Martin Sirait - 2023
When, how, and why do states take what kind of action vis-à-vis protests? This article tackles these under-researched questions with respect to Vietnam and Indonesia. The theoretical frame applied focusses on the state-society nexus and in-built biases of the capitalist state and its actions. It draws on Poulantzas' idea of the state as a material condensation of the relationship of social forces as well as on Jessop's "strategic-relational approach" and his concept of the "state in a capitalist society." The method used is Protest Event Analysis, using data for 2016 and 2017 from four Indonesian and Vietnamese newspapers. This is complemented by data drawn from various newspapers on protests and state reactions for the period 2018-2020. The focussed theory frame used helps to explain similarities and differences of state reactions in Indonesia and Vietnam. Both states may govern protest in slightly different ways. Ultimately, however, both those states' reactions indicate strong similarities in that they serve to maintain existing patterns of political, economic, and socio-cultural domination and the accumulation of capital as the very basis of the capitalist economy. To put these tentative findings to the test, longer-term data and cross-regional comparisons on state reactions to protests should be used.
VIETNAM
INDONESIA
PROTEST
STATE IN A CAPITALIST SOCIETY
PROTEST EVENT ANALYSIS
The state in a capitalist society: protests and state reactions in Vietnam and Indonesia/ Jörg Wischermann, Thi Viet Phuong Dang & George Martin Sirait - 2023
When, how, and why do states take what kind of action vis-à-vis protests? This article tackles these under-researched questions with respect to Vietnam and Indonesia. The theoretical frame applied focusses on the state-society nexus and in-built biases of the capitalist state and its actions. It draws on Poulantzas' idea of the state as a material condensation of the relationship of social forces as well as on Jessop's "strategic-relational approach" and his concept of the "state in a capitalist society." The method used is Protest Event Analysis, using data for 2016 and 2017 from four Indonesian and Vietnamese newspapers. This is complemented by data drawn from various newspapers on protests and state reactions for the period 2018-2020. The focussed theory frame used helps to explain similarities and differences of state reactions in Indonesia and Vietnam. Both states may govern protest in slightly different ways. Ultimately, however, both those states' reactions indicate strong similarities in that they serve to maintain existing patterns of political, economic, and socio-cultural domination and the accumulation of capital as the very basis of the capitalist economy. To put these tentative findings to the test, longer-term data and cross-regional comparisons on state reactions to protests should be used.
VIETNAM
INDONESIA
PROTEST
STATE IN A CAPITALIST SOCIETY
PROTEST EVENT ANALYSIS